Practice · Commercial Disputes and Insolvency
Projects and land
Advisory and litigation on infrastructure project structuring, land acquisition, zoning, environmental compliance and public-private partnerships.
Reviewed
Infrastructure and project work spans the full life of a project: the land it is built on, the regulatory approvals it needs, and the contracts under which it is financed and constructed. It touches public law as often as private commercial law.
Land and regulatory clearance
A project's land base has to be acquired. Where the State does the acquiring, that happens under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, which replaced the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. The 2013 Act carries its own process for compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement, and its own timetable. Zoning and development permission disputes arise where a proposed use does not align with sanctioned plans, and are contested before planning authorities and, where necessary, the courts. Environmental clearance and continuing compliance run through the National Green Tribunal and pollution control boards, which handle both the grant of clearances and enforcement action for non-compliance.
What the 2013 Act does not allow
The conditions below are not procedural niceties. Where one of them is missed, the acquisition itself is open to challenge.
Land cannot be acquired for a private company's project without the prior written consent of 80 per cent of the affected families. Where the project is a public-private partnership and ownership of the land stays with the government, the figure is 70 per cent. Consent comes before the award, not after it.
Acquisition cannot begin without a social impact assessment and a public hearing in the affected area. The urgency provision in section 40 and the exemptions in section 105 are the narrow exceptions, and an assessment run as a formality once the decision is already made is not the assessment the Act asks for.
Possession cannot be taken until compensation has been paid or tendered. Section 38 sets the order of events and the months within which payment has to be made.
Irrigated multi-cropped land is protected. It may be acquired only as a last resort, and the state government has to fix a limit on how much of it can go.
Land acquired and then left unused for five years, or for the period set for the project if that is longer, does not simply stay with the acquiring body. Section 101 returns it to the owner or puts it in the state land bank.
Challenging government action
Where a government authority's decision (a clearance refused, a licence withheld, a tender process conducted improperly) is arbitrary or exceeds its statutory power, the remedy lies in a writ petition before the High Courts under their constitutional writ jurisdiction. This is a distinct track from ordinary civil litigation, addressed specifically to the legality of governmental or statutory action, and it extends to representation before sector regulators and licensing authorities in both advisory and contested settings.
Structuring the transaction
Project transactions, including public-private partnerships and project financing arrangements, are structured across their own lifecycle: feasibility and regulatory planning, transaction structuring, procurement and bid management, and financial closure. Procurement for such projects involves tender conditions and bid documentation specific to the sector and the funding structure, and the concession or project agreement that follows has to allocate risk (construction risk, demand risk, regulatory risk) between the public authority and the private party in terms that hold up over the project's operating life, which for infrastructure assets can run for decades. What a developer or a public authority has to decide, at the structuring stage, is how that risk allocation is set, since reopening it after construction has begun is considerably harder than settling it in the concession agreement.
How is compensation calculated under the 2013 Act?
Section 26 fixes the market value as the highest of three figures: the value specified under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 for registering sale deeds in the area, the average sale price for similar land in the nearest village or vicinity, and, where land is acquired for a private company or a public-private partnership project, the consented amount. Value is taken as on the date of the notification under section 11. The First Schedule multiplies that value by a factor of 1.00 to 2.00 in rural areas, as the appropriate Government notifies according to the distance from an urban area, and by 1 in urban areas, and adds the value of assets attached to the land or building under section 29. Section 30(1) then adds a solatium equal to one hundred per cent of the compensation, and section 30(3) adds twelve per cent per annum on the market value from the date the social impact assessment notification is published.
When does a project need environmental clearance, and from whom?
Paragraph 2 of the Environment Impact Assessment Notification, 2006 (S.O. 1533(E), 14 September 2006) requires prior environmental clearance for every new project or activity listed in its Schedule, and for their expansion or modernisation, before any construction work or preparation of land is started, other than securing the land. Under paragraph 4, a Category A project is cleared by the Central Government in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change on the recommendation of an Expert Appraisal Committee, and a Category B project by the State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority on the recommendation of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee. Paragraph 7 sets four stages: screening, which applies to Category B only, scoping, public consultation and appraisal.
Which documents establish title to land?
Section 17(1) of the Registration Act, 1908 makes registration compulsory for an instrument of gift of immovable property and for any other non-testamentary instrument that creates, declares, assigns, limits or extinguishes a right, title or interest of the value of INR 100 and upwards in immovable property. Section 49 provides that such a document, if unregistered, does not affect the property and is not received as evidence of the transaction. Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 allows a sale of tangible immovable property of that value to be made only by a registered instrument, and a contract for sale does not by itself create an interest in the land. The record of rights is kept under each state's land revenue law, and the weight it carries is set by that statute.
What this covers
- Project structuring
- Structuring and risk allocation advisory for infrastructure, public-private partnership and project finance transactions.
- Procurement and bid management
- Advisory on tender conditions and bid documentation for project procurement.
- Land and zoning advisory
- Advisory and representation in land acquisition proceedings, zoning challenges and development permission disputes.
- Environmental regulatory defence
- Representation before the National Green Tribunal, pollution control boards and other environmental authorities.
- Writ petitions
- Filing and defending writ petitions before High Courts challenging governmental action and regulatory overreach.
- Representation before statutory bodies
- Representation before sector regulators, licensing authorities and statutory boards.
- Contract negotiation for projects
- Negotiation and drafting of concession agreements and project contracts across the deal lifecycle from feasibility to financial closure.
Reference
Statutes and instruments
Forums
Sectors this practice works in
Advocates
- Adv. Adithya Karthik K
Commercial Disputes, Insolvency & Transactions
- Adv. Harsha Swaroop P
Commercial and Projects; Criminal, Family & Child Rights
