Skip to content
Juris Eagle crestJuris EagleAdvisoryArbitrationLitigation

Practice · Commercial Disputes and Insolvency

Civil disputes

Representation in commercial suits, shareholder disputes and civil litigation before trial, commercial and appellate courts.

In the Commercial Disputes and Insolvency group.

Reviewed

Commercial and civil disputes cover the range of litigation a business or individual may face outside the specialised statutory forums: breach of contract, recovery of money, shareholder conflict and the interim relief that often determines how a dispute is actually resolved.

Commercial suits and recovery

A dispute arising from breach of a commercial contract, or a claim for recovery of money due under one, is ordinarily filed as a civil suit, and where the claim value crosses the threshold set by the Commercial Courts Act, it proceeds before a designated Commercial Court with its own timelines and case management procedure. These suits turn heavily on the contract's own terms and on what the evidence shows about performance and breach.

Interim relief

Many commercial disputes are decided, in practical terms, at the interim stage: an injunction restraining a party from a threatened action, an order attaching assets before judgment, or another urgent application filed to prevent a loss that final relief, months or years later, could not undo. Interim applications are drafted and argued separately from the main suit and often shape how the rest of the litigation proceeds.

Shareholder and corporate conflicts

Disputes between shareholders (allegations of oppression of a minority shareholder, mismanagement of the company, or a governance conflict between promoters) are heard before the National Company Law Tribunal rather than the ordinary civil courts, under the Companies Act's provisions on oppression and mismanagement. Directorship disputes and contractual deadlocks between joint venture or shareholder parties raise similar questions about which forum has jurisdiction and what relief it can grant.

Appeals

A civil or commercial dispute rarely ends with a single judgment. Appeals proceed through the High Courts and, in matters that raise a substantial question of law, to the Supreme Court of India, and a party involved in first-instance litigation has to plan for that appellate stage from the outset rather than treating it as a separate decision to be made later.

What is the limitation period for a commercial suit?

Usually three years, counted from a starting point that depends on the kind of suit. The Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 assigns specific articles to specific suits: Article 54, for example, gives a suit for specific performance of a contract three years from the date fixed for performance or, if no date is fixed, from when the plaintiff has notice that performance is refused. Where no other article applies, Article 113 gives three years from when the right to sue accrues. Section 3 requires a suit instituted after the period to be dismissed, subject to sections 4 to 24, although limitation has not been set up as a defence.

Is mediation mandatory before a commercial suit is filed?

Yes, unless the suit contemplates urgent interim relief. Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 bars the institution of a suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief until the plaintiff has exhausted the remedy of pre-institution mediation. In Patil Automation Private Limited v. Rakheja Engineers Private Limited (17 August 2022) the Supreme Court held the requirement mandatory, with prospective effect, and held that a plaint filed in breach of it is to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The time spent in pre-institution mediation is not counted towards limitation.

What is the "specified value" of a commercial dispute?

INR 3 lakh. A commercial dispute of a specified value of not less than INR 3 lakh is tried under the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 rather than as an ordinary civil suit. The figure was reduced from INR 1 crore by the amendment of 2018, the same amendment that inserted section 12A.

What the law does not allow

A written statement after 120 days. In a commercial suit, the proviso to Order VIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, as amended for commercial disputes, permits a written statement beyond thirty days only up to 120 days from the date of service of summons; after that the defendant forfeits the right to file it and the court shall not take it on record. The Supreme Court held the period mandatory in SCG Contracts (India) Private Limited v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Private Limited (12 February 2019).

A time-barred suit saved by the defendant's silence. Section 3 of the Limitation Act, 1963 requires a suit filed out of time to be dismissed although limitation has not been pleaded, so a failure to raise it does not cure the delay.

What a claimant has to decide, before the limitation period runs out, is whether the claim carries a genuine case for urgent interim relief, since that alone decides whether the suit can be filed at once or must first go to mediation.

What this covers

Commercial suits
Breach of contract, recovery and enforcement actions before Commercial Courts.
Shareholder disputes
Minority oppression, mismanagement and corporate governance conflicts before the National Company Law Tribunal.
Interim relief
Injunctions, attachment orders and urgent interim applications.
Corporate and contractual conflicts
Directorship disputes, contractual deadlocks and cross-entity commercial conflicts.
Civil recovery suits
Money recovery and specific performance suits before civil courts.
Appellate proceedings
Appeals before High Courts and the Supreme Court arising from commercial and civil litigation.

Reference

Statutes and instruments

Each instrument links to its page, which lists where else this site relies on it.

Forums

Which of these each office reaches is on the office pages: Bengaluru, Mumbai and New Delhi.

Sectors this practice works in

The sector page states the industries within it and the regulators and forums involved.

Advocates

  • Adv. Adithya Karthik K

    BBA, MBA (International Business), LL.B., LL.M. (Corporate & Commercial Law), Diploma in Banking & Insurance Law, PG Diploma in IP Law (NLSIU)

    Commercial Disputes, Insolvency & Transactions

  • Adv. Ravi Kumar

    BA, MBA (HR), LL.B., LL.M. (Corporate & Commercial Law), Diploma in Banking Law

    Litigation, Banking & Employment

Notes

All notes on Civil disputes